Heat Pump vs Split System: Which Is Best for You?

HVAC

Blog
// Posted by Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.

Are you thinking about getting a new air conditioning and heating unit? Or maybe you want to learn more about your current setup? It's key to know the differences between a heat pump and a split system. Each has its pros and cons, and the right choice for your home depends on many things.

Things like gas availability, energy efficiency, how well it heats and cools, installation and upkeep needs, environmental impact, and cost matter. This article will look into the main differences between heat pumps and split systems. We'll help you figure out which is best for your home's comfort, efficiency, and wallet.

Key Takeaways

  • Heat pumps run on electricity, while furnaces can use gas, propane, or oil.
  • Heat pumps offer energy-efficient heating and cooling, while furnaces provide more heat output.
  • Heat pumps don't produce carbon monoxide, but furnaces require annual inspections for safety.
  • Split systems offer zoning and temperature control, but ductless mini-splits are more efficient.
  • Factors like climate, home insulation, and budget will help determine the best HVAC system for your needs.

Understanding Heat Pumps and Split Systems

When looking at home HVAC systems, you have two main choices: heat pumps and split systems. It's important to know the differences to pick the right one for your home.

What is a Heat Pump?

A heat pump is an HVAC system that pulls heat from the air or ground outside and changes it for heating or cooling. They use electricity and can be in ducted or ductless systems. Heat pumps are efficient, using less energy than traditional systems because they move heat instead of making it.

What is a Split System?

A split system has an air conditioner and a gas furnace, all connected by ducts. It uses both electricity and gas for heating and cooling. This makes it a good choice for homes with ducts already installed.

Knowing how heat pumps and split systems work can help you choose the best one for your home. This depends on your needs and budget.

Pros and Cons of Heat Pumps

Heat pumps are a great choice for heating and cooling your home. They have both good and bad points compared to traditional systems. Knowing the advantages of heat pumps and disadvantages of heat pumps helps you pick the best option for your home.

Advantages of Heat Pumps

Heat pumps don't need natural gas, which is a big plus. They work like air conditioners in summer, cooling your home. This is great for those who want a system that can handle both heating and cooling.

They are also very energy efficient. Heat pumps move heat instead of making it, which saves a lot of energy. This means lower bills for you over time.

Disadvantages of Heat Pumps

But, heat pumps have some downsides too. They might not warm your home as much as a gas furnace in very cold places. They need good insulation, which can make the setup costlier.

Also, in very cold areas, heat pumps can struggle to pull enough heat from the air. You might need to use extra heaters, which can up your energy use and bills.

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system depends on your specific needs and your home's climate. Think about the pros and cons of heat pumps to make a choice that fits your home and life.

Pros and Cons of Split Systems

Split systems are great for heating and cooling your home. They have both good and bad points to think about. Knowing these can help you choose the best one for your home.

Advantages of Split Systems

Split systems are known for their strong heating. They use gas furnaces that can make a lot of heat. This makes them perfect for really cold places. Plus, with regular checks, they are safe to use.

They also work well in homes that aren't well-insulated. You can place the furnace and air conditioner where it's best, which is great for older homes or small spaces.

Disadvantages of Split Systems

A big downside is needing a gas line. If you don't have one, you might have to pay more to get one. Also, if not kept up, split systems can be dangerous, causing carbon monoxide poisoning.

Getting a split system costs about the same as a heat pump. But, the energy bills might be higher because of local rates and the system's efficiency. So, while they heat well and are flexible, they might not save you money or be the best choice for everyone.

Identifying Your Current System

Figuring out if you have a heat pump or a split system can be hard. They look similar from the outside. But, there are signs that can help you tell which one you have.

If you get a gas bill, chances are you have a gas furnace and a split system. But, if your thermostat has emergency or auxiliary heating options, you probably have a heat pump.

Looking at your indoor unit can also give you clues. If you see gas pipes and a flue pipe, you likely have a gas furnace and a split system. If you don't see these, it's more likely you have a heat pump.

Checking the outdoor unit can also help. Heat pumps and split systems have different outdoor units. Look at the brand, model, and any extra features or labels on the unit.

Knowing the differences between heat pumps and split systems helps you figure out your current HVAC setup. This way, you can make a smart choice when upgrading or replacing your system.

  1. Look for a gas bill - if you have one, you likely have a gas furnace and a split system.
  2. Check your thermostat for emergency or auxiliary heating options - this indicates a heat pump.
  3. Inspect your indoor unit for gas pipes and a flue pipe - this signifies a gas furnace and a split system.
  4. Examine the outdoor unit for brand, model, and any additional features or labels to identify the system.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system for your home involves several key factors. The availability of gas and energy efficiency are crucial. They can greatly affect your choice.

Availability of Gas

If you have natural gas, a split system with a gas furnace might be cheaper. Gas furnaces usually heat more affordably than electric heat pumps. But, if you don't have gas, an electric heat pump is a great choice.

Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is key when picking between a heat pump and a split system. Ductless mini-split heat pumps lose less energy than systems with ducts. This means lower bills and less harm to the environment.

Today's heat pumps work better in cold weather, making them good for areas with harsh winters. Homeowners should look at energy efficiency ratings like SEER. This helps find the best system for their needs and climate.

By looking at gas availability and energy efficiency, homeowners can make a smart choice. This choice should match their budget, climate, and eco-friendly goals when deciding between a heat pump and a split system.

Heating and Cooling Capabilities

Heat pumps and split systems both have their own strengths and weaknesses in heating and cooling. It's important to know how well they work to pick the best one for your home.

Heat pumps are usually better at cooling than heating, especially in cold places. But, new heat pumps, even those made for cold weather, can heat well too. On the other hand, split systems with gas furnaces can heat more in very cold areas.

When it comes to cooling, heat pumps and split systems with air conditioners work about the same. The choice often depends on what you prefer, how efficient you want to be, and if the systems work well together.

Think about your home's climate and heating needs when choosing between a heat pump and a split system. In mild areas, a heat pump might be more efficient and save money. But, in really cold places, a split system with a gas furnace is better for strong heating.

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system should be based on your home's specific needs, energy efficiency goals, and local climate.

Installation and Maintenance Requirements

Heat pumps and split systems have different installation and maintenance needs. Knowing these differences helps you choose the best HVAC for your home.

Installing a heat pump is simpler than a split system because it doesn't need much ductwork. Mini-split heat pumps are especially easy to install, needing only a small wall hole for the units to connect. Split systems, however, require more work to set up the ducts for air distribution.

Both heat pumps and split systems need regular checks and upkeep to work well and safely. Tasks include cleaning or replacing air filters, checking refrigerant levels, and keeping the outdoor unit in good shape. Ductless mini-splits might need more filter checks.

  • Heat pumps work as a 2-in-1 system, cooling and heating your home.
  • Mini-split heat pumps are ductless and have several air handlers for better control over different areas.
  • Getting a mini-split system costs more upfront because of the air handlers.
  • Ductless systems use less energy than traditional HVAC setups.
  • They do need more upkeep, especially with their filters.

When picking an HVAC solution, think about the installation and maintenance needs of heat pumps and split systems. Talking to a professional installer can help you understand what your home needs.

Environmental Impact

Heat pumps are better for the environment than split systems with gas furnaces. They have a lower carbon footprint and produce fewer greenhouse gases. This makes them a greener choice.

Heat pumps use electricity, not fossil fuels, so they don't emit greenhouse gases. Split systems with gas furnaces do release carbon emissions. But, you can lessen their environmental impact with regular upkeep and correct setup. Heat pumps also don't have the risk of carbon monoxide leaks, a danger with gas systems.

  • Heat pumps have a smaller environmental impact compared to split systems with gas furnaces.
  • Heat pumps do not produce any direct greenhouse gas emissions, while gas furnaces in split systems do release carbon emissions.
  • Heat pumps also eliminate the risk of carbon monoxide leaks, a potential issue with gas-powered systems.

Today's heat pump technology is even better for the planet. They use advanced compressors and eco-friendly refrigerants. These refrigerants don't harm the ozone layer, making heat pumps even greener.

Heat pumps are more energy-efficient than split systems. They pull heat from the air, even in cold weather, and move it inside. This means less energy is used for heating and cooling, leading to lower bills and a smaller carbon footprint for homeowners.

Cost Comparison

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system means looking at costs. Both the initial and ongoing expenses are key to the total cost.

Upfront Costs

The initial costs for heat pumps and split systems are usually close, ranging from $3,000 to $10,000 for a new setup. The exact cost depends on the system's size, efficiency, and complexity. Yet, some heat pumps like geothermal or solar-powered ones might cost more upfront due to extra equipment and setup.

Operating Costs

Operating costs can differ a lot between heat pumps and split systems. Heat pumps, especially ductless mini-splits, are often more energy-efficient and lead to lower bills. This is especially true if you're switching from a propane or oil furnace.

On the flip side, split systems with gas furnaces might be cheaper to run in some areas. This depends on the local electricity and gas prices.

Heat pumps can make 1.5 to 3 times more energy than they use, saving you money over time. Split systems work best in certain climates, possibly leading to lower costs in warmer areas.

When deciding between a heat pump and a split system, think about both the upfront and ongoing costs. This will help you find the best option for your budget and energy use.

Mini-Splits vs Heat Pumps

When it comes to heating and cooling your home, you have two main options: mini-split heat pumps and traditional heat pumps. Both use heat pump technology but have key differences. It's vital to know these differences before choosing.

Mini-split heat pumps are a ductless system. They combine the flexibility of mini-splits with the heating and cooling of heat pumps. They don't need ductwork, so you can control the temperature in different zones. This makes them efficient and customizable, especially for homes without ducts.

Traditional heat pumps are central systems that use ducts to spread heated or cooled air. They control the climate of your whole home. But, ductwork can lose energy due to leaks. Also, installing ducts for a traditional heat pump can be costly.

Mini-split heat pumps are usually cheaper upfront than traditional heat pumps. They cost between $1,500 and $5,000. Traditional heat pumps, on the other hand, can cost $3,500 to $7,500 for air source models and $13,000 to $36,000 for geothermal.

Both mini-split and traditional heat pumps can be very efficient, earning the ENERGY STAR label. But, their efficiency ratings vary. Mini-splits need a higher HSPF and SEER to meet ENERGY STAR standards.

The choice between mini-split and traditional heat pumps depends on your home's needs, budget, and energy goals. Knowing the differences between these systems helps you make a choice that fits your heating and cooling needs.

Mini-split and traditional heat pumps both save energy for heating and cooling. But, the right choice for you depends on your home's layout, ductwork, budget, and preferences. Consider the pros and cons of each to decide what's best for your home's comfort and efficiency.

heat pump vs split system

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system for your home's heating and cooling is tough. Each system has its pros and cons. The right choice for you depends on several factors. Let's look at the main differences between heat pumps and split systems to help you decide.

Energy Efficiency

Heat pumps are usually more energy-efficient, especially in mild climates. They can be up to five times more efficient at cooling than heating. This makes them ideal for controlling temperatures all year. Split systems might be better in very cold areas, offering more heating power.

Heating and Cooling Capabilities

Split systems with gas furnaces are great for very cold weather, providing strong heating. Heat pumps are versatile, offering both heating and cooling efficiently.

Installation and Maintenance

Installing split systems is more complex because of the separate indoor and outdoor units and the ductwork needed. Heat pumps, especially ductless mini-splits, are easier to install and can save on maintenance costs over time.

Cost Considerations

Heat pumps might cost more upfront, but they can save on energy costs over time. Split systems with gas furnaces are cheaper in areas where gas is cheap and available.

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system depends on your specific needs, climate, and budget. Think about energy efficiency, heating and cooling abilities, installation, and ongoing costs. This will help you make a choice that offers the best comfort and value for your home.

Climate Considerations

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system depends on your area's climate. Heat pumps work best in moderate climates. They can't get enough heat from the air in very cold places. In such cases, a split system with a gas furnace might be better. This is because the furnace can add extra heat when the heat pump can't keep up.

In hot, humid places, both heat pumps and split systems with air conditioners work well. But ductless mini-split heat pumps might be more efficient. They can cool your home better in these conditions.

Think about the climate considerations for heat pumps vs split systems. Also, consider the heat pump performance in cold climates and split system performance in hot climates. This will help you choose the best HVAC system for your home.

In places with extreme weather, a split system might be the better choice. It can handle the climate's demands well. But in moderate climates, a heat pump could be the better option. It provides both heating and cooling without needing extra gear.

Zoning and Temperature Control

Heat pumps and split systems have different benefits when it comes to zoning and temperature control. Split systems use one thermostat for the whole home. Heat pumps, like ductless mini-splits, let you control the temperature in different zones or rooms.

Being able to set the temperature in certain areas can make your home more comfortable and save energy. With a heat pump, you can heat or cool only the rooms you're using. This saves a lot of energy compared to treating the whole house as one big zone.

  • Heat pumps, especially ductless mini-splits, offer built-in zoning capabilities, allowing you to control the temperature in different rooms or zones independently.
  • Split systems typically rely on a single thermostat to manage the temperature throughout the entire home, making it more challenging to achieve personalized comfort and energy savings.
  • Adding zoning capabilities to a split system is possible, but it may be more complex and costly than the integrated zoning features of a ductless mini-split heat pump system.

Heat pumps are great for homes with changing occupancy, multiple floors, or unique designs. They let you adjust the heating and cooling to fit your needs. This way, you can save energy and keep your home comfortable.

When deciding between a heat pump and a split system, think about the zoning and temperature control options. Knowing the differences can help you pick the best system for your home. This choice should match your comfort and energy efficiency goals.

Aesthetics and Visibility

Heat pumps and split systems have different looks and how they show up in your home. Split systems hide their air handlers in closets or basements. This makes them less noticeable and fits well with your home's look.

But, the indoor units of ductless mini-split heat pumps are more visible. They are wall or ceiling mounted. Yet, they are made to look sleek and don't stand out much. Homeowners might think about the visibility of the indoor units when choosing between heat pumps and split systems.

  • Mini-split systems can achieve SEER ratings over 30 on the cooling side, leading to high energy efficiency.
  • Ductless mini-split systems with built-in zoning can offer precise control over the comfort in different areas of a home, offering flexibility in heating and cooling solutions.
  • Ductless systems may have less powerful air filters compared to ducted filtration systems, affecting the ability to rid homes of allergens, dust, and odors.
  • Line aesthetics of ductless systems may be seen as an eyesore due to the visible line that runs from the indoor to the outdoor unit.

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system depends on what you like and your home's needs. Think about the aesthetic considerations for heat pumps vs split systems and the visibility of the indoor units. This way, you can pick the system that suits your lifestyle and home design best.

Conclusion

Choosing between a heat pump and a split system depends on your home's needs, climate, and budget. If you have gas, a split system with a gas furnace might save you money. But, if gas isn't an option, a heat pump is a great choice.

Heat pumps are more energy-efficient, especially ductless mini-splits. However, split systems work better in very cold areas for heating. Think about gas availability, energy use, heating and cooling power, installation and upkeep, environmental impact, and costs to pick the best system for your home.

By comparing heat pumps and split systems, you can make a smart choice for your home. This ensures your home stays cozy and uses less energy for many years.

HVAC Technician installing a electric heat pump
About Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.
Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is a locally owned heating and air conditioning company that provides sales, service, and installation of any type of heating or cooling in your home or light commercial building.

Although the name Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is new, Mr. Richard Gilmer has been in the business of keeping his neighbors comfortable since 1998. As our presence in the HVAC contractors industry has evolved, we decided to change the name of our business to better reflect our commitment to the Middle TN area.

Our core values include implementing economically friendly products and practices to better contribute to the health and home of our customers. We are EPA certified and ensure that all refrigerant is recycled and all equipment is disposed of as per environmentally-safe standards. Our service techs and installers are trained to conduct business with minimal disruption to your daily lifestyle so that the only impact we make is a positive one

FAQ

What is the difference between a heat pump and a split system?

Heat pumps take heat from the air or ground outside and change it for heating or cooling. Split systems have an air conditioner and a gas furnace. They use ducts to connect the outdoor unit and indoor unit.

What are the main advantages of heat pumps?

Heat pumps don't need gas and don't have the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning. They work like air conditioners in summer. But, they might not heat as much as gas furnaces, and they need good insulation to work well.

What are the main advantages of split systems?

Split systems can heat more than heat pumps and are safe with regular checks. They're a good choice if your home isn't well-insulated.

How can I identify if I have a heat pump or a split system?

Check your gas bill; if you have one, you likely have a gas furnace and a split system. Look for emergency or auxiliary heating on your thermostat. If you see gas pipes and a flue pipe, you have a gas furnace and a split system.

What factors should I consider when choosing between a heat pump and a split system?

Think about gas availability, energy efficiency, heating and cooling performance, installation and maintenance needs, environmental impact, and cost.

How do heat pumps and split systems differ in their heating and cooling capabilities?

Gas furnaces in split systems can heat more in very cold weather. But, modern heat pumps, even in cold climates, heat well. Both heat pumps and split systems with air conditioners cool well.

What are the differences in installation and maintenance requirements between heat pumps and split systems?

Putting in a heat pump is easier than a split system because it doesn't need ducts. Both systems need regular checks and upkeep to work right and safely.

How do heat pumps and split systems compare in terms of environmental impact?

Heat pumps are better for the environment than split systems with gas furnaces. They use electricity and don't emit greenhouse gases. Split systems with gas furnaces release carbon emissions, but you can reduce this with proper maintenance and setup.

What are the differences in upfront and operating costs between heat pumps and split systems?

Heat pumps and split systems have similar initial costs, but their ongoing costs differ. Heat pumps, especially ductless mini-splits, use less energy and lower utility bills. Split systems with gas furnaces might be cheaper to run in some areas, depending on local energy prices.

What is a mini-split heat pump and how does it differ from a traditional heat pump?

Mini-split heat pumps combine the benefits of ductless mini-splits with heat pump technology. They don't need ducts and let you control the temperature in different areas or rooms.

HVAC Technician installing a electric heat pump
About Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.
Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is a locally owned heating and air conditioning company that provides sales, service, and installation of any type of heating or cooling in your home or light commercial building.

Although the name Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is new, Mr. Richard Gilmer has been in the business of keeping his neighbors comfortable since 1998. As our presence in the HVAC contractors industry has evolved, we decided to change the name of our business to better reflect our commitment to the Middle TN area.

Our core values include implementing economically friendly products and practices to better contribute to the health and home of our customers. We are EPA certified and ensure that all refrigerant is recycled and all equipment is disposed of as per environmentally-safe standards. Our service techs and installers are trained to conduct business with minimal disruption to your daily lifestyle so that the only impact we make is a positive one

Related Blog Posts

How to Reset Your Thermostat
How to Reset Your Thermostat
If your thermostat stops working on a chilly fall day, try resetting it by turning off the power and restoring it after a few minutes. If issues persist, consult an HVAC professional for assistance.
Read More →
Is Water Dripping from Your A/C Dangerous?
Is Water Dripping from Your A/C Dangerous?
Is your A/C dripping water? While some condensation is normal, persistent dripping could signal issues like a clogged drain line or dirty air filter. Schedule a maintenance check to keep your system running smoothly!
Read More →
Crossville Heating and Cooling: Essential HVAC Terms
Crossville Heating and Cooling: Essential HVAC Terms
Navigating the world of HVAC—Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning—can be overwhelming. Understanding these HVAC terms can empower you to make informed decisions about your system’s care and operation.
Read More →
Is It Safe to Run Your AC Without a Filter?
Is It Safe to Run Your AC Without a Filter?
Running your AC without a filter, even temporarily, can lead to significant problems with your system and indoor air quality.
Read More →
Choosing the Right Size for Your AC Unit
Choosing the Right Size for Your AC Unit
Choosing the right size for your AC unit involves more than just picking a model. Properly sizing your unit, understanding SEER ratings, and conducting a load calculation are crucial for optimal performance and efficiency.
Read More →
Fall Bucket List: Essential Activities and Events in Crossville, TN
Fall Bucket List: Essential Activities and Events in Crossville, TN
Fall in Crossville and Cumberland County is a season brimming with vibrant events, outdoor adventures, and festive traditions.
Read More →
Preparing Your Home for Pre-Fall Weather: HVAC, Plumbing, and Generator Tips
Preparing Your Home for Pre-Fall Weather: HVAC, Plumbing, and Generator Tips
Preparing your home for fall involves more than just adjusting your thermostat. Proper HVAC, plumbing, water treatment, air quality, and generator maintenance ensures a smooth transition into the new season.
Read More →
Is Your Air Conditioner Leaking Water?
Is Your Air Conditioner Leaking Water?
While some water dripping from your AC is normal, excessive or persistent leaks can indicate serious issues.
Read More →
Frozen Air Conditioner? Here's How to Fix it.
Frozen Air Conditioner? Here's How to Fix it.
Regular maintenance and understanding the common causes of freezing will help keep your AC running smoothly and prevent future problems.
Read More →
HVAC Technician worker outside working on a ac unit

Need HVAC Service? 
Contact Us Today!

Stay comfortable year-round! Don't wait for a breakdown. Click here to schedule your HVAC repair or installation today!